Sustainable site-based management of collecting pressure on palaeontological sites

Feedback questionnaire

Due to the wide range of views on this subject, we would like to measure the range of reactions to this paper in order to identify areas of consensus. We will not accept anonymous questionnaires.

To return to the management of collecting pressure on palaeontological sites page, click here (http://www.geoconservation.com/EHWH/docs/fossil.htm)

If you are unable to submit the questionnaire online, please download the word version and return your completed questionnaire as an attachment by e-mail to GeoConference@jncc.gov.uk. The word version of the questionnaire can be found at http://www.geoconservation.com/EHWH/docs/fossilqus.doc.

Please complete the details and press the submit button at the end.

1. Name:
 

2. Contact e-mail/telephone number:
 

3. Interest (scientist, landowner, site manager, collector, student, other (specify)):
 

4. Are you prepared for your comments to be attributable and available on line?

5. Do you agree or disagree that a site based approach to the management of palaeontological heritage is a useful approach?

6. Why? (for or against)
 

7. Is it the best approach or is there a better way?

8. Do you agree or disagree that management is as much about the relationship between user groups as it is about a site?

9. Why? (for or against)
 

10. Do you agree or disagree with the principles of site management as defined in this paper? (yes or no as appropriate)

(a) Sites and the fossil material should be conserved in the best possible condition:
(b) KSIS and representative collections should be placed in museums
(c) Fossils should be saved from destruction where ever possible:
(d) Collecting and/or the palaeontological interest should be accessible to as wide a public as possible:
(e) Management should be effective:
(f) Management should be inclusive and agreement on the management approach should be sought between landowners and interest groups:
(g) The collection of fossils should be undertaken within the law:
(h) Collecting should be undertaken in a responsible and sustainable manner:

Any comments on the above?

11. Do you agree or disagree with the conservation objectives? (yes or no as appropriate)

(a) Material available for scientific study (in situ if required):
(b) Key scientifically important specimens to registered museum collections:
(c) Fossil material is recovered from sites where it would be lost if not collected:
(d) Fossils collected in a sustainable fashion through responsible collecting:

(e) THe site remains available for scientific study and use:

Any comments on the above?

12. Do you accept or oppose the sale of fossil specimens?

13. Why?
 

14. Are the proposed 10 questions of management useful?

15. What questions are missing?
 

16. Are the three broad management options correct or are there others?

17. Do you agree or disagree with the considerations for management? (yes or no as appropriate)

(a) The implications for the relationship between the different user group/s:
(b) The effectiveness of the chosen approach:
(c) The interests and responsibilities of the landowner/site operator:
(d) The costs of the selected/preferred management approach:

18. Do you believe that it is possible to have regulation even when it is not possible to enforce that regulation?

19. If yes, why?

20. Do you agree or disagree with the management options identified for:

(a) The West Dorset Coast:
(b) Conesby Quarry:
(c) Loders Bypass:
(d) Horn Park Quarry:

If you disagree, why?

And finally

21. Is there anything missing in this paper? Do you have any other comments?


Please submit your responses by using the button below:

If you are unable to submit the questionnaire online, please download the word version and return your completed questionnaire as an attachment by e-mail to GeoConference@jncc.gov.uk. The word version of the questionnaire can be found at http://www.geoconservation.com/EHWH/docs/fossilqus.doc.

If, having filled in the online questionnaire you are unable to submit it directly, please 'select all', and copy and paste the form into a blank word document and send your response by e-mail to GeoConference@jncc.gov.uk.

  To return to the management of collecting pressure on palaeontological sites page, click here (http://www.geoconservation.com/EHWH/docs/fossil.htm)